Contact Us

(941) 779-9320

9908 Gulf Dr.

Anna Maria, FL 34216

10AM-5PM & "On Call"


Our Team

Top Sellers & Record Breakers

Experienced, Dedicated and Knowledgeable

  • Sue Carlson

    Broker / Owner

    Hello! My name is Sue Carlson. I have been coming to Anna Maria Island for years, luckily, visiting my parents who spent winters here to escape northern Michigan winters! After taking travel groups to faraway places around the world, always thinking the grass was greener on the other side of the fence, I have finally found my piece of paradise right here in the United States, on the Gulf Coast of Florida and Anna Maria Island!

    My greatest joy, now, is helping others find the same relaxing, vacation spot through my company, Coastal Cottages AMI, or a lasting home with An Island Place Realty!

  • Tanya McCormick-Edwards

    Sales Associate

    Hello! My name is Tanya McCormick-Edwards. I have lived in the Bradenton area for over 25 years and have a wealth of experience in the vacation rental industry, helping clients find their perfect vacation spot. Transitioning into real estate sales is allowing me to help those clients make their dream come true... to have a piece of paradise! I am also a singer in the area playing at many of the local venues!! So call the Singing Realtor and lets find your perfect home!!!

  • Billi Gartman

    Sales Associate

    Anna Maria Island is magic. It took me about one day to figure that. I flew in for my best friend's wedding and pretty much never left. It was the lifestyle that hooked me. The lifestyle when you feel like you are on vacation every day; you can walk to some of the most beautiful beaches in the world; watch amazing sunsets nightly; trade in the suit, tie and heals for swim attire and flip flops. It is a feeling of freedom and tranquility.

    My family and I love living on Anna Maria Island and everything that comes with it. I have been involved in Real Estate since I unpacked my bags. From vacation rentals to residential real estate, I have dealt with the best. I know the island, the community and the market. I would love to help you invest in you living the Anna Maria Life.

  • Lance Collins

    Sales Associate

    “Greetings! I have been a homeowner and resident of Central Florida for over eleven years, including the last four here on Anna Maria Island. This island has always been my family’s favorite escape, so we, my wife, Eva, my dog, Buddy, and I, have now made it our permanent paradise.

    I have over twenty five years of real estate experience, including commercial, corporate and now residential. During that time I have been directly involved in the acquisition or disposition of over $500,000,000 in real estate assets throughout the United States. I now bring this extensive experience and knowledge to work for you.

    Since joining the team here at An Island Place Realty, finding people their dream home or vacation property here on Anna Maria Island is my sole focus. I look forward to helping you achieve your dreams and goals.”

  • Doug Shaw

    My wife, Michele, and I are natives of Traverse City, Michigan. In 2013 we decided to “live the dream” and purchase a vacation home on Anna Maria Island. Working with Sue and An Island Place Realty made the process go seamlessly, and her obvious knowledge of the island and personal approach was an unexpected bonus.

    After making the decision to retire after almost 37 years as a practicing chiropractor, my wife and I made the permanent move to the “perfect place,” and I have started a new career in real estate. Working with Sue at An Island Place Realty was the obvious choice!

    Spending 36+ years as a doctor of Chiropractic and taking care of people have taught me the value of truly listening to people’s concerns and desires to help them achieve their goals.

    My commitment to hard work, excellence, honesty, combined with an in depth knowledge of the available properties on the island are the philosophy that drive my real estate practice. Please call to schedule an appointment today to see if “The Real Estate Doctor” can help you achieve your goals! I am anxious to work with you!

  • Pam Lee

    Sales Associate

    Pam Lee, known by most islanders as the friendliest post office girl in Anna Maria, wears two hats, one as a friendly postal clerk and one as a friendly realtor, willing to go out of her way to help you find your Florida home!

    Originally from Michigan, Pam has lived on Anna Maria Island for 11 years, having the adventurous spirit to move lock, stock, and barrel to relocate to paradise. She has never looked back!

  • Rita Payne

    Broker Associate

  • Keith Barnett

    Sales Associate

    Hello! My name is Keith Barnett. I was born in Miami and raised on Grand Bahama Island, where my father, Captain Ray Barnett, was instrumental in the early development of the island. I have spent the last 25 years residing on the Gulf Coast of Florida, 17 of them on Anna Maria Island. I followed in my father's footsteps, serving in the U.S. Coast Guard, and am a licensed 100 ton Master, advanced open water scuba diver, and rescue diver. I am owner of Barnett Blinds, and my wife, Rebecca, and I still travel frequently to the Bahama Islands.

  • Dennis Clark

    Broker Associate

    Hello, my name is Dennis Clark. I came to Anna Maria Island from Hollywood, Florida, via southern California. My background is in both residential and commercial real estate, and my greatest satisfaction is in working with investors on the local, national, and international levels. I have a strong background in sales, communications, electronics, and advertising. I would like to help you find your place in this paradise that has a proven history of record appreciation!

  • Angela Lester

    Broker Associate

    ANGELA LESTER, is a life Florida native from Lakeland, Florida. Her licensed Real Estate career included Broker/owner of her Real Estate company, which has rendered over 30 years in Real Estate. Earning a degree in Architecture at U.F., she began her career as an Architect, and she later progressedas the First licensed and certified ‘Woman’ Building Contractor in state of Florida awarded with a career highlight of‘Home of the Year’ in 1991.

    She is now a broker/associate in Real Estate at ‘An Island Place Realty’ and long-time resident on Anna Maria Island. She is involved in the community by volunteering at Anna Maria Chamber of Commerce, The Center of Anna Maria, and The Studio on Gulf and Pine.

  • Sylvia Marnie

    Sales Associate

    Sylvia Marnie is a native of Great Britain. She came to Anna Maria Island 23 years ago with her Canadian husband, their two children and three suitcases.. and never left!

    She has been involved in real estate her entire life, developing an extensive knowledge in residential and investment properties. Sylvia takes pride in pinpointing the right fit for all, whilst providing a highly personal touch.

    Her free time is spent, fostering dogs for a local shelter. She has recently taken on the role of President of the Island Players, our local theatre. And she is proud to be a Guardian Ad Litem for children in our area

  • Steve Barbagallo

    Sales Associate

    My Commitment to You

    Provide courteous, professional service in a timely and efficient manner in all transactions affecting the sale and/or purchase of your home.
    Utilize proprietary state-of-the-art tools and proven best practices to enhance all aspects of the home buying and selling process.
    Keep you informed and knowledgeable throughout the entire transaction.

    Skills and Expertise Provided to You

    Sales and negotiation experience in top customer service companies for 25+ years
    Realtor and Property Manager with expertise in Florida Gulf Coast island properties from Siesta Key to Anna Maria Island
    Multiple award winner for Customer Service Excellence, Leadership, and Team Management.
    Business entrepreneur and successful company builder.